Skip to content

Alleged Falls porch pirates arrested

At about 10 AM on Christmas Eve morning, 2 District – Niagara Falls uniformed officers from the Niagara Regional Police Service (NRPS) were waved down by a member of the public in the area of Portage Road between Valley Way and Morrison Street, in Ni
The recovered loot, displayed on an NRPS cruiser. NRPS PHOTO

At about 10 AM on Christmas Eve morning,  2 District – Niagara Falls uniformed officers from the Niagara Regional Police Service (NRPS) were waved down by a member of the public in the area of Portage Road between Valley Way and Morrison Street, in Niagara Falls.

According to a police statement released later that day, the member of the public reported that they had just witnessed the theft of a package from the porch of a house on Portage Road.

Officers began searching the area for a male and female suspect.  Police said officers located the male and female nearby.  They were found in possession of approximately $60 of children's Star Wars toys.

John Dennis McFaul, 35, of Niagara Falls, was arrested and charged with the crimes of:

  • Possession of Stolen Property Under $5000
  • Possession of a Schedule 1 Substance (Cocaine)

Michelle Amber Zappavigna, 36, of Niagara Falls was arrested and charged with the crime of:

  • Theft Under $5000

Police said that McFaul and Zappavigna were driven from the area and released on a Form 10 undertaking with future court dates.

Police ask that anyone who may have witnessed this incident call 905-688-4111, extension 1022200.